If your punch bait is real sticky it will work, if its mostly fiber then it wont hold too well to that. I also tried double action hooks and dip bait back when I mostly used dip baits and I never got them to work. I think I hooked a couple fish, but missed every fish that didnt swallow it and run. I would be able to set the hook and stick 20 times more fish with a super sharp #6 treble.